GitHub vs GitLab: The important thing variations

Many individuals ask me: “Which distributed model management system ought to I exploit for my programming challenge, GitHub or GitLab?” It is not that straightforward a query. Let’s break it down, we could?

First, do you really want a distributed model management system (VCS) in any respect? A VCS’s (aka a Supply Code Administration (SCM) system) job is to make it simple for a number of builders, designers, and crew members to work collectively on the identical challenge. It ensures everybody has the identical entry to the newest code and modifications are tracked. 

That is simpler mentioned than finished. 

That is why Linus Torvalds thinks of Git as his different nice invention. Git is free, open-source, and quick. It additionally works higher than its predecessors, similar to Apache Subversion, Concurrent Variations System (CVS), Perforce, and Rational ClearCase. There is a cause why so many VCS companies have “Git” of their names. 

In fact, you should use Git by itself by yourself server. If all you are doing is constructing a program in-house, a neighborhood Git occasion is all you want. You may also use Git as a centralized VCS by yourself servers or cloud. There isn’t any must subscribe to a VCS service when you possibly can construct your individual. With this mannequin, you possibly can simply run a challenge along with your crew and companions scattered all through the world.

In the event you do want the bells and whistles of a hosted Git service, nevertheless, then it is time to have a look at GitHub and GitLab.

GitHub is the oldest of the companies. It was developed by Chris Wanstrath, P. J. Hyett, Tom Preston-Werner, and Scott Chacon utilizing Ruby on Rails in February 2008. Due to its first-mover benefit, GitHub turned the house base of many open-source code repositories.

Additionally: GitHub requires contributions to new cybersecurity Advisory Database

GitLab got here later; Ukrainian builders Dmitriy Zaporozhets and Valery Sizov created GitLab in 2011. From day one, GitLab was designed to be a set of collaboration instruments in addition to a code repository service.


Nonetheless, they give the impression of being extra like one another than not. Each run on Linux servers, include concern trackers, and provide a variety of third-party integrations and import instruments. 

Additionally they each have command-line interfaces (CLI) for superior builders, and so they additionally provide web-based interfaces for brand spanking new programmers. In GitLab’s case, the consumer interface makes use of GitLabs’ personal Pajamas design system and is written in Vue.js. GitHub’s consumer interface, Desktop, is out there as a Home windows or macOS program. You may also now use Visible Studio with GitHub

Whereas each help open-source, the repositories themselves use a blended programming mannequin. GitLab used an open-core enterprise strategy. On this mannequin, the GitLab Neighborhood Version stays free and open-source, whereas the GitLab Enterprise Version has extra options and comes with help. As for GitHub, whereas its code accommodates some open-source code, it is not an open-source challenge. 

Nonetheless, basically, each provide web-based repositories with open-source, Git-based code administration and native file adjustments with a distant repository. If all you need is fundamental Git performance however with another person to fret over retaining Git up and working, both service will do properly for you.

In fact, some folks nonetheless dislike GitHub as a result of Microsoft acquired it in 2018. To some, Microsoft will all the time be The Evil Empire, irrespective of how a lot Microsoft reveals it now helps open-source strategies and software program — or how typically Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella says he loves Linux. That mentioned, that is by no means been that huge an element. Whereas some customers did flee GitHub for GitLab and Atlassian BitBucket on the time, it was by no means the mass exodus some had anticipated.  

That mentioned, GitHub is clearly the 800-pound gorilla of the VCS world. In response to the programming instruments firm JetBrains, 77% of builders use GitHub recurrently in comparison with 40% for GitLab and 25% for BitBucket.

Additionally: GitHub permits two-factor authentication mechanism via iOS, Android app


The core distinction is GitLab has Steady Integration/Steady Supply (CI/CD) and DevOps workflows built-in. GitHub enables you to work with the CI/CD instruments of your alternative, however you will must combine them your self. Sometimes, GitHub customers work with a third-party CI program similar to Jenkins, CircleCI, or TravisCI. 

One other vital distinction is GitHub places velocity first, whereas GitLab focuses on reliability. 

Particularly, GitHub advocates merging new branches with the grasp department. That approach, you are already able to shortly deploy, when you additionally speedily reinstate your outdated model if one thing goes awry. 

In GitLab’s workflow, you create a number of steady branches past the grasp. At a minimal, you will have manufacturing and pre-production steady branches. This implies you will must undergo a multiple-step testing course of. A single code evaluate upon the merge request is not sufficient. 

In fact, you can also make both one work the best way you need, however there is a clear distinction in the popular strategy.

One other core distinction is that GitLab provides you a whole software program growth answer. They promote themselves as a whole DevOps platform for a cause. That mentioned, GitLab does provide integrations with some third-party packages and platforms similar to Jira, Microsoft Groups, Slack, Gmail, and quite a few different apps and platforms.

GitHub, then again, provides fewer companies inside its personal program however provides methods to combine with many exterior packages and companies. These embody software program that GitHub has labored on to combine with the service and tons of of different packages through GitHub Market.


Each companies provide free plans. These include limitless private and non-private repositories. That could be sufficient for you in case you’re a solo programmer or have a small crew. However, if programming is your organization’s residing, you will want extra. 

It is tough to match GitHub and GitLab’s pricing. It is apples and oranges. I counsel beginning with their free plans to get an concept of how your workflow operates on every platform after which look into subscribing to the one which works finest for you. 

The prices of subscriptions must be the least of your considerations. I’ve used each and, for my small-time programming functions, they’ve labored extraordinarily properly. 

That mentioned, GitLab’s Premium plan prices $19 a month per consumer, whereas the full-featured Final plan is $99 a month. As for GitHub, the Group plan is $40 a 12 months per consumer and the Enterprise plan is $200 a 12 months per consumer. However, the satan is the main points, you could properly discover you will must pay for extras irrespective of which service you lastly subscribe to. 

Do not let value be your information. What actually issues is which one will provide you with the instruments and companies you could develop your software program to one of the best of your means. 

Related Articles

Back to top button